SALINA, Kan. - Monday, Aug. 22, Kansas staged its own contribution to one of the most important national climate change discussions in decades, thanks to the Eisenhower Center and the KSU Institute for Civil Discourse. The topic: TransCanada's Keystone XL oil pipeline for Alberta tar sands oil. Final decision on XL's final leg is due soon from the U.S. State Department.
TransCanada (TC) wields a big stick: Canada is our single largest oil supplier, ahead of Venezuela and Saudi Arabia.
The Aug. 23 Salina Journal story noted the strong audience response to one suggestion. The Kansas Legislature gift-wrapped a present of an estimated $50 million tax abatement that TC doesn't need -- and that no other states gave. When Jim Prescott, TransCanada's representative, insisted his company is a responsible, good neighbor, one citizen suggested TC's good neighbor policy should extend to gifting that $50 million to desperate Kansas kids and schools, where most of the taxes would/should have gone anyway. This reverse-gift idea received strong audience applause.
Prescott did not make that offer.
The article concluded by quoting a TC-sympathetic landowner urging that humans not be "subservient to plants and animals," demanding that oil companies drill or "develop resources" when and where necessary, and concluding with the sentence, "Individuals and organizations who call themselves environmentalists are nothing more than obstructionists." The article ended, noting this also drew a round of applause.
Casual readers could be left with the impression that the audience shared this view of "environmentalists." Not necessarily.
Many with environmental -- or more accurately, human -- concerns were in that audience. They were in sympathy with a large Winnebago parked outside, covered with the logo, "Stop the Pipeline."
It was no doubt headed for Washington, D.C., where the largest national climate change civil disobedience movement in history is taking place. By Labor Day, nearly 2000 people will have participated in a mass White House demonstration. One hundred-fifty have already been arrested for Martin Luther King-like, non-violent civil disobedience action to encourage President Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to reject the project's final leg.
Obstructionists? Not really.
Oil spill concerns expressed in Abilene are justified. This highly-pressurized 1400-pound-per-square-inch pipeline, some of which meets Candadian, not U.S. safety standards, will stretch from Alberta, Canada through Kansas to the Gulf of Mexico. The underground gusher destroying Montana's pristine Yellowstone River should be warning enough about the limitations of "secure" oil pipelines, terrorists or no.
Real as these concerns are, however, they pale in comparison to the major issue. The tar sands, like Uncle Remus' tar baby, are deadly and already have us stuck in their trap.
When nominated for President, Barack Obama promised to ensure that "the rise of the oceans [will begin]to slow and our planet [will begin] to heal." With tar sands among the dirtiest of all fossil fuels, that ain't happenin' -- yet.
Miles of Alberta's ancient Boreal forests, one of the world's best carbon sinks, have already been stripped and trashed, along with two billion tons of rock and soil, to reveal bitumen tar. Heated to 900 degrees Fahrenheit, it emits up to three times the greenhouse gas of regular drilling and refining.
Once pristine Alberta waters are rapidly becoming a toxic toilet bowl. The oil industry consumes some 15 percent of the Athabasca River's winter flow -- enough to supply a city of 2 million. Tailings ponds (really lakes so large they can be seen from space), are required by Alberta law to keep waste out of groundwater. They don't work.
Some 2.9 million gallons per day of slurry containing arsenic and mercury leach daily into an underground aquifer or drain into the river. Cancer is rampant.
If fully developed, the tar sand wasteland will be larger than Greece, about 54,000 square miles.
Certainly, this is a case of Kansas economic injustice. Companies using our territory for their profits should pay their fair share in taxes.
But focusing only on this is like insisting on our share of the swag from a pirate ship who just plundered our clipper, rammed a hole in its hull, and sank our cargo of food, clean air and water to a 3-thousand foot grave.
Those who can fathom this will know that hanging our hopes here amounts to hanging our neighbor -- and eventually ourselves. As Chief Seattle said, "Whatever befalls the earth befalls the sons and daughters of the earth ... All things are connected like the blood which unites one family."
Want to stop this folly? Use less gas and sign the anti-pipeline petition. Go to www.350.org/sign/tar-sands and sign your name. Or call the Secretary of State. Our future is in your hands.