« Previous Story | Front Page | Next Story »

Can Racial Bias Impact American Helpfulness in Haiti?

By Lucy Belnora
Analysis | January 14, 2010

MANHATTAN, Kan. - When terrible things happen, it's natural for people to turn their attention to the problems, evaluate the situations and figure out what needs to be done in order to make things better.

"For me, an area of moral clarity is: you're in front of someone who's suffering and you have the tools at your disposal to alleviate that suffering or even eradicate it, and you act." - Paul Farmer

Not everyone reacts with the same amount of compassion or willingness to help. In some situations, some people are repulsed or made uneasy by the pain and suffering of others. People can turn away and avoid involvement or the feelings of uneasiness by blaming or fearing the victims.

Did biases towards the victims prevent effective life-saving responses to the Hurricane Katrina victims in New Orleans? Could the same thing happen in Haiti? Under what circumstances do people sometimes blame and criticize victims, deeming them unworthy of help?

When assessing the amount of help someone needs, people's perceptions can be skewed by their racial biases, according to a recent Kansas State University study.

In both New Orleans, and this week in Haiti, the media and the rescuers are talking about the need for 'security' to prevent riots, although no riots have been observed. The emphasis on preventative security measures seems to be causing most of the supplies to be sequestered at the airport in the Haitian capital. Rescuers are remaining huddled together there rather than immediately distributing the first aid, food and water.

Fears of security kept the police from reaching New Orleanians stranded at the Convention Center too. By gunpoint, even one county sheriff in Louisiana stopped unarmed, hungry and beleaguered families from crossing a bridge and leaving that city. That sheriff justified his actions to by claiming that the thirsty refugees could be dangerous.

According to news coverage at the time, the police in New Orleans were more focused on preventing looting than on getting help to the stranded citizens.

Could a similar perception of the Haitian victims slow rescuers, stopping them from leaving the guarded airport compound in Port-au-Prince in time to save lives?

Donald Saucier, K-State associate professor of psychology, and psychology graduate students Sara Smith, Topeka, and Jessica McManus, Maineville, Ohio, surveyed undergraduate students a year after Hurricane Katrina to examine their perceptions of the hurricane victims and the helping response.

The researchers created a questionnaire that evaluated the participants' perceptions of Hurricane Katrina victims. The questionnaire evaluated whom the participants perceived to be the victims based on measures like gender, race and socioeconomic status.

The results showed that participants generally thought people impacted by Hurricane Katrina were black and lower class.

"What we wanted to do was see how perceptions of victims of Hurricane Katrina would interact with things like racism," Saucier said. "We wanted to look at how much the participants felt that the victims may have been to blame for their own situation in Katrina."

The researchers measured differences in the participants, including their levels of conservatism, empathy and racism.

The findings showed that when recalling victims of Hurricane Katrina, participants who were less racist thought the victims did not receive adequate help from the government. Participants who were more racist thought the victims received adequate government assistance and were at fault for their situation.

The survey also asked questions that measured whether the participants thought the victims had enough time to evacuate and whether they had enough resources to get out before the hurricane hit.

"We asked the participants to make personality attributions about individuals, such as whether they thought the victims were lazy, stupid, sinful or unlucky," Saucier said.

"If they said they were lazy, stupid or sinful, they were putting more blame on the victims for the situation. If they said they were unlucky, they took away the blame."

The results suggest that perceptions of the victims and the Hurricane Katrina situation depended on the participants' individual differences, including their levels of racism. Negative perceptions and placing blame on the victims were generally associated with the participants' perceptions that the situation was less of an emergency and that the victims needed less help.

Although the findings can't fix what happened to the victims, the study helps show how people interpret the situation.

The researchers study the effects of group membership, and groups can be categorized in various ways, including by gender, race and socioeconomic status.

"Since I do not believe that there should be different recommendations for people living in the Bronx and people living in Manhattan, I am uncomfortable making different recommendations for my patients in Boston and in Haiti." - Paul Farmer

William Ryan, in his book Blaming the Victim, critiqued Daniel Patrick Moynihan's 1965 work The Negro Family: The Case for National Action (aka the Moynihan Report). Moynihan's book summarized his own theories about ghetto formation and intergenerational poverty. Ryan's critique cast the Moynihan theories as subtle, and not so subtle, attempts to divert responsibility for poverty from social structural factors to the behaviors and cultural patterns of the poor.

Why do people diminish victims' rights to justice? Some have theorized that many people believe in a 'just world.' The 'just world' belief involves the rationale that the people who are injured only receiving their 'just' due.

Sometimes, people who believe that the world has to be fair may find it hard or impossible to accept a situation in which a person is unfairly and badly hurt, unless the victim has done 'something' to deserve his or her fate. This may be a reason why people believe that rape victims 'asked for' their assaults or people unable to escape an oncoming hurricane are 'just lazy.'

Other theories posit that people distance themselves from those that are injured or harmed as an way of meeting their own needs to protect their own sense of invulnerability. In other words, if the potential victim avoids the behaviors of the past victims then they themselves will remain safe and feel less vulnerable - or so they may feel compelled to believe.

Human beings have a natural tendency to pre-judge people who are different. That prejudgement, or prejudice, may begin harmlessly as a way of deciphering and understanding the world. If you meet three purple people and they all speak Spanish, then would you be prejudice if, after that, you believe that all purple people speak Spanish? Perhaps not, unless your prejudice causes you to withhold care or community services to those people that you assumed were unrelated to you and, therefore, undeserving of your compassion.

Studies also show there are specific factors that cause someone to help a member of their own group more than others. In helping situations, discrimination is often expressed by not giving help to those of a different group than the helper.

"Rather than doing something bad, the person who chooses not to help the out-group member fails to do something good," Saucier said.

"I think this illustrates the complexity of how prejudice is expressed in contemporary society despite the social norms that usually serve to suppress the expression of prejudice."

Saucier said discrimination is often expressed only when other factors are present that would justify the action and rationalize it as something other than an expression of prejudice.

Factors that contribute to the justification of not helping someone include the time it would take to help; the risk, effort, difficulty and financial cost involved; the distance between the potential helper and the person needing help; the level of emergency and the ambiguity of the helping situation.

The researchers said the Hurricane Katrina situation had several elements that studies show trigger acts of discrimination, such as a high cost of help, a high level of emergency and a large amount of time and effort required to help.

"Shuttling back and forth between what is possible and what is likely to occur is instructive and a lot of what shapes our sentiment." - Paul Farmer

"We want to examine how the perception of someone that you're going to be helping is going to affect your perception of how much help they need and how much help you'll want to give," Saucier said.

Though it's unlikely that the Kansas researchers can fix the beliefs and attitudes that lead to discrimination, more KSU studies are now underway to try to change the behavior that is expressed when related to discrimination.

The KSU researchers are exploring other helping situations and how other group memberships affect the helping response.

Images depict Haitian civilians receiving assistance in a camp set up outside the airport by the ethnically diverse Brazilian Army in Port-au-Prince, in the aftermath of the 2010 Haiti Earthquake. Photographs were produced by AgĂȘncia Brasil, a public Brazilian news agency.

Post your own comment here

Do you want to read more? You've only just scratched the surface at the Kansas Free Press. We have so much more to read! Nearly all of the pieces published here are timeless and relevant, regardless of when the articles were first published. To discover more, please take a look at our Table of Contents or go back to our Front Page.

Our sponsors help us stay online to serve you. Thank you for doing your part! By using the specific links below (clicking through from our site) to start any of your online shopping, you are making a tremendous difference. By using the shopping links provided on a Kansas Free Press page, you are directly helping to support the Kansas Free Press:

About This Page

This page contains just one story published on January 14, 2010. The one written previous to this is titled " No Room for Partisanship" and the story published right after this one is "Some Concrete Ways That Kansans Can Help Haitians"

Our most current stories are always updated on our Front Page.

Other Archives

Interested in other topics? You may wish to poke around in our Table of Contents to find other sections and archives.

Do you want to explore pieces written by specific authors? You can find archives for KFP writers by reviewing our complete Directory of Authors and Writers here.

Recently Featured Stories

My Response As a Kansan to Jessica Valenti

Jessica Valenti has come on board The Nation magazine to fill in for Katha Pollitt as the feminist columnist while Pollitt is on leave to write a book. I've found reading Valenti's columns thought-provoking and insightful. She often takes …
Of Angels and God's Dogs

There might be a whole group of us out there--people who value our relationships with animals on a par with our ties to people. "Get over it--it was just a dog" does not resonate with us. Our society places …
Of Angels and God's Dogs

There might be a whole group of us out there--people who value our relationships with animals on a par with our ties to people. "Get over it--it was just a dog" does not resonate with us. Our society places …
Roots of the n-word

While N-word dialogue has slackened following Saline County Commissioner Gile's use of it recently, the word still has great power. So, let's look inward at the N-word. To reach a much deeper path to understanding, simply go to Ad …
Corporate Tax Reform

Basehor, Kans.--For an interesting twist on the corporate tax debate, look at Alan Sloan's opinion in the April 29 issue of Fortune Magazine. In all of the froth about corporate taxation, neither proponents of tax reduction, nor corporate critics, …

News and Opinion

Get Connected

See our FB page!
Subscribe for free!
[Feeds & Readers...]
Follow Kansas Free Press on Twitter, too!
Make Kansas Free Press your home page!

Journalists, sign in.

We're reader supported!

Whenever you use the specific links below to begin any of your online shopping, a portion of your sale goes directly towards the support of this site.

Tech Depot - An Office Depot Co.

Our sponsors help us stay online to serve you. Thank you for doing your part! By using the specific links above (clicking through from our site) to start any of your online shopping, you are making a tremendous difference. By using the shopping links provided on a Kansas Free Press page, you are directly helping to support the Kansas Free Press.

Thank you for your help!

Notices & Policies

All of our Kansas Free Press journalists are delighted that you are here. We all hope that you come here often, sign in and leave us comments, and become an active part of our community. Welcome!

Our writers are credentialed after referral to, and approval by, the editor/publisher of KansasFreePress.com. If you are interested in writing with us, please feel free to let us know here. We are always looking for Kansans who want to write about Kansas!

All authors here retain their own copyrights for their original written works, original photographs and art works. They welcome others to copy, reference or quote from the content of their stories, provided that the reprints include obvious author and website attribution and links to the original page, in accordance with this publication's Creative Commons License.

Our editor primarily reviews stories for spelling, grammar, punctuation and formatting and is not liable or responsible for the opinions expressed by individual authors. The opinions and accuracy of information in the individual stories on this site are the sole responsibility of each of the individual authors. For complete site policies, including privacy, see our Frequently Asked Questions. This site is designed, maintained, and owned by its publisher, Everyday Citizen Media. The Kansas Free Press, KansasFreePress.com, and Kansas Free Press are trademarked names.

© Copyright, 2008-2012, all rights reserved, unless otherwise specified, first by the respective author, and then by KFP's publisher and owner for any otherwise unreserved and all other content.